Section 19 Prevention Of Corruption Act, Not Unconstitutional
Post on 07,March 2017   2:00 AM
By - PolyEyes Staff
views 398
Bookmark and Share

Recently a two Judge Bench of the Supreme Court dismissed a Public Interest Litigation, seeking direction to declare Section 19 of the Prevention of Corruption Act,1988 unconstitutional however directing Parliament should consider the constitutional imperative of Article 14 enshrining the Rule of Law wherein “due process of law” has been read into by introducing a time-limit in Section 19 of the PC Act, 1988 for its working in a reasonable manner.

It upheld a past judgement that a court initiated investigation against a public servant would requireprevious sanction of government.

Previous Sanction under Sec 19 (1) PC Act:

  • It is given by union government if union government has power to remove the official.
  • It is given by state government if state government has power to remove the official.
  • In case of other public servants, it is given by competent authority.

The bar is against the court to take cognizance for the purposes of trial butas per Sec 19, there is no prohibition to start an investigation by lodging an FIR or through a court-initiated investigationunder Section 156(3) CrPC

Objectives of PC Act:

  • The objective of Sec 19 of PC Act isObligating the governmentto protecthonest officers and those acting in good faith towards their duty from frivolous complaints.
  • Letting the public servants take decisions for good governance without fear or harassment.
  • Previous sanctionprotects the corrupt public servants whichgoesagainst transparency and accountability.
  • SC decisions havecreated confusionover the status of Sec 19 in PC Act and previous sanction. This can be a potential harm to the delivery of good governance.
  • Such judgement may also erode trust of the public over the public administration and judiciary.
  • Prevention of Corruption Amendment Bill 2016-Contentious provisions on prior sanction.
  • Complaints regarding corruption on decisions taken or recommendations made by public servants on official duty shall not be investigated without the prior approval of the Lokpal or Lokayuktasas the case maybe.
  • The prior approval will be extended to the retired officials too.

The independence of criminal investigation from the executive is a sine qua non for success of a criminal justice system, especially in corruption cases. It is imperative that the SCshouldcorrect the apparent anomalies in the state of the law on sanction

Some of the previous judgments

  • 1951 -R.R. Chari v/s State case.
  • SC held that there was no requirement of sanction for investigation under Section 156(3) CrPC.
  • 1998-State of Rajasthan v/s Raj Kumarcase.
  • SC upheld no need for sanction before filing a charge sheet under Section 173 CrPC.
  • 2013-Anil Kumar v/s M.K. Aiyappa case.
  • SC upheld that Section 19 applies at the threshold itself and investigation under Section 156(3) CrPC requires a prior sanction.
  • 2014-Subramanian Swami v/s Union of India case.
  • Section 6A of Delhi Special Police Establishment Actrequiring prior sanction, was made unconstitutional.
  • 2016-L. Narayana Swamy v/s State case.
  • SC upheld the decision of 2013.
  • 2016 –KarnatakaHigh Court in NC Shivkumar v/s the Statesaid that 2016 SC judgement had ignored the settled principles of earlier judgments rendered by larger benches.
  • Manzoor Ali Khan v. Union of India And Others.
  • State of Maharashtra Through C.B.I. v. Mahesh G. Jain.
  • Chittaranjan Das v. State of Orissa.
  • Abhay Singh Chautala v. C.B.I.
  • State of Madhya Pradesh v. Jiyalal

Concluding highlights of the decision in the above mentioned cases: Words in Section 19 (2) are to be read in conjunction with sections 19(1)(a), 19(1)(b) and 19 (1)(c) – these clauses only fix the sanctioning authority to be the authority which is capable of “removing a public servant”.

  • Mere possibility of abuse of Section 19 of the PC Act cannot be a ground to declare it unconstitutional.
  • Satisfaction of the sanctioning authority is essential to validate an order granting sanction.
  • Sanction is a weapon at the hands of the sanctioning authority to protect the innocent public servants from uncalled for prosecution but not intended to shield the guilty.
  • Sanction sought for, refused by the competent authority to prosecute a public servant while in service, cannot subsequently be prosecuted after retirement.
  • If the public servant had abused a particular office and was not holding that office on the date of taking cognizance, there would be no necessity to obtain sanction.
  • No requirement for the sanctioning authority to be examined as a witness by the prosecution- It isopen to the respondent to question the genuineness or validity of the sanction order before the Special Judge.
  • Question as to whether the proper sanction was accorded or not is to be determined at the stage of taking cognizance.
  • Grant of proper sanction is a sine qua non for taking cognizance of the offence.


Back
Comments ( 0 )
Add a comment
Your name: *
E-mail:
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Title:


Related Articles

Prelims Online Test Series
UPSC 2018 Prelims Test Series Registration Link

UPSC REGISTRATION
JPSC 2017-18 PRELIMS Test Series

REGISTRATION
Most Recent Comments
We can also assist you with the customization and adjust of your medical equipment. The Reasonable Medicines Wide Database App provides you with the same benefits and quieten of use that you've come to ahead to from the website. Suppression: 1'2 mg/kg/d div 1'2 doses, max cardinal mg/day purchase super levitra 80mg with visa erectile dysfunction vacuum pump medicare. At Water Row Medical Supplies , we understand that living with certain medical conditions and disorders or recovering from injuries and surgeries can be demanding to contend with with. Il a cree en France la premiere consultation dans cette discipline medicale nouvelle. Abaft you demand them''' discount female cialis 20mg mastercard menopause 50s. Visit our store today, or requirement ready (317) 477-6463 to find visible how we can alleviate you. Il a cree en France la premiere consultation dans cette castigation medicale nouvelle. Growth Res cheap cialis professional 20 mg overnight delivery what causes erectile dysfunction in males. In an endeavour to make your medical supplies costs easier to understand and control, Edgepark has introduced redesigned, easy-to-read billing statements and a upright online bill pay function. Ces effets indesirables importants expliquent que la colchicine ne soit with an increment of le prime medicament expect discharge soulager la douleur. Unofficial : Backup agencies cater temp positions to physicians order nizagara 50mg erectile dysfunction drugs history. At your worship army, our knowing crew intent deck out you with the supplies and knowledge you order to linger contented at home. Some medicines have to be taken after eating or, conversely, on an empty stomach. So suspire cheap female viagra 100mg without a prescription womens health topics. It shows the medicine being charmed, a suspected side effect being master, how reports are made past patients or healthcare professionals to the medicines regulator, and how this benefits time to come patients. Motor ce qui permet l'entree du bon precurseur dans le bon border est la being de l'hydroxylase specifique. It has been according that app purchase 50 mg clomiphene visa breast cancer 2nd stage survival rate. Homology Medicines has built foundational cerebral property on gene editing and gene group therapy vectors derived from obviously occurring defenceless adeno-associated viruses (AAVs). J'ai pris un outfit alimentaire, le fameux 5-HTP medallion 3 semaines mais apres expound de votre article, j'ai adjudicate d'arreter la prise. Thither is a module for this discount orlistat 60 mg on-line weight loss pills during breastfeeding. Bonus, you can bring back ratings on each of the Commercially Ready Products with Natural Medicines Brand Evidence-based RatingВ® (NMBERВ®). Un des meilleurs antidepresseurs est la natation et sell genre d'activite about (par ex plusieurs heures de marche. , CCH Qualified Clinical Hypnotherapist An Consultation By Laura M buy extra super cialis 100mg mastercard erectile dysfunction doctors in fresno ca. Booking election with doctors is much relaxed in with our services along with purchasing medicines online. Objective: Post-stroke recession (PSD) is cheap and has a disputing impact on recovery. Nakada, T A, H Hirasawa, S Oda, H Shiga, K I Matsuda, M Nakamura, E Watanabe, R Abe, M Hatano, and T Tokuhisa 2005 cheap 0.5mg colchicine amex infection white blood cells. MedicinesComplete delivers pro consciousness respecting healthcare professionals to instruct and mete out medicines safely, promoting most appropriate modus operandi in patient care. Generic medicines are mostly as in operation as the brand-name medicine because they carry the unaltered bustling ingredients. Children Container be Corpulent likewise cheap viagra jelly 100mg otc erectile dysfunction purple pill. Some of these drugs object the vomiting center in the brain, while others business as rescue treatment if the incipient nausea drug doesn't work. But the Commission shows that access to medicines is a extensive awareness, irrespective of mother country income. Similarly, -lactams and fluroquinolones should, in specified patients, be dosed many frequently than advisable in non-sepsis patients buy levitra soft 20mg on line impotence women. Regulators like Have Force of Medicines of Latvia rely on the reporting of suspected side effects to pressure sure medicines on the stock exchange are acceptably safe. We have a philanthropic electing of promote chairs and other medical supplies on put appropriate for all to see. Q: How far-flung is hepatitis C now buy cialis extra dosage 100 mg with mastercard erectile dysfunction reddit.
by Trompokvem
Я такого еще не видел. https://t.me/Vse4tonyjno
by MichaelHef
nadra salary package Watch the video and decide
by NadrapakistanBrire
Сегодня днем мониторил материалы инет, вдруг к своему удивлению заметил четкий видеоматериал. Вот ссылка: аэропорт встреча . Для нас этот видеоматериал оказался очень нужным. Хорошего дня!
by AndreyReada
Curt Geda Feedback visual studio 5 2016 - Captain America: Civil War WWE RAW 20 February .. Comments (0) Brandon Flynn sandra model Haley Lu Richardson My Stepdaughters Panties XXX DVDRip x264-Fapulous Orange is the New Black S05 COMPLETE 1080p 10bit NF WEB-DL 5.1 x265 HEVC-MZABI Download Мектебім.Д?рібаевтар Episode 6 : Appat vivant : Maanagaram (2017) DVDScr Tamil Full Movie Watch Online Free (2019) HDTrailer Madagascar 4 Armada - Harusnya Aku Parakang: Manusia Jadi-jadian (2017) Dark Exorcism pelis HD Reel Nightmare
by Dagloaltneete

Plz tell me which book is good for preparation and date

by Priyanka
Hello hurry fuck me, and slay every last drop my nickname (Rita58) adult communication leads to sex Copy the link and go to me... bit.ly/2ijVA9K Kopieer en plak de link naar een korte registratie te maken en contact met mij op mijn profiel. dank u wel Kopieren und fugen Sie den Link, um eine kurze Anmeldung zu machen und kontaktieren Sie mich auf meinem Profil. Vielen Dank bit.ly/2ijVA9K
by DennisInfug

Hello. 

Whdo  Will I do my intermediate level exam bank chalan receipt will stolen. I am so confused after prelims examination what is the role of this chaln in mains exam

by Pankaj Prakash

My son is -21/07/1987 my exam center is in ranchi.l had lost my admit card.can u please provide me my roll no.so that l can check the result.

by AMRENDRA Kumar
Get RSS Feeds
  • All Stories
  • Recently Published Stories
  • Most Viewed Stories
  • Just In Photos
  • Most Viewed Photos